33 Carroll Street, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963
33 Carroll St
4 beds
3,800 Sq.Ft.
2017 BUILT
1 Acres LOT

33 Carroll Street, Sag Harbor.

This sophisticated 3800 sf barn-style home offers a modern lifestyle tucked on a quiet country lane at the gateway to the Village of Sag Harbor. Recently crafted from custom specifications to maximize volumes it has an abundance natural sunlight within the double-height living space and uniquely elegant professional grade kitchen.

Elevated finishes are found throughout the property. The architecture is thoughtful and refined. The exterior is clad in a clear cedar plank complemented by cedar shakes, standing seam rooflines, and dark grey farmhouse windows. The interior palette is of honey-toned wood accented by chic warm grays.

The oversized 20'ceiling living room with wood-burning fireplace has a wall of sliders to a bluestone patio and pool area in a picture-perfect manicured yard. A striking staircase, framed by the wall of glass foyer, leads to a bridge on the second floor separating the guest bedrooms.

The heart of the home Is the chef-designed kitchen with a large Carrera marble island surrounded by ample marble counters and storage space. Professional-grade stainless appliances include a 48" AGA Range and side-by-side 36" Subzero fridge and 30" wine fridge, double Miele dishwashers and a warming drawer, stainless farmhouse-sink and prep-sink and a Wolff range hood anchored on a wall of beautiful marbled tilework. The adjacent open dining space is perfect for both casual and formal meals.

The enormous ground floor master suite has a gas fireplace, luxurious master bath with steam shower and soaking tub and a custom-fitted walk-in closet. A glass slider opens out directly to a side patio and spa pool. Upstairs you'll find 3 ensuite bedrooms including a second-floor junior master suite all with custom-fitted walk-in closets and a second laundry room.

The lower level was designed for future expansion with 10' ceilings and 2 egress windows for additional bedrooms and living space.

In the garden is a 15 x 30' Gunite pool and 7 x 15' spa pool, outdoor shower and generous bluestone patio with room for outdoor dining and lounging. The pool house is equipped with a full bath, kitchenette with beautiful custom cabinetry, marble countertops, a fridge and dishwasher drawer and large storage closet.

Less than a mile into the Village with easy access to public tennis courts at Mashashimuet Park, this stunning home is a pure delight, easy to maintain and surely the perfect home base in the center of the Hamptons for enjoying country life on the edge of an exciting world-class bustling town.

Key Details

Total Bathrooms
Year Built
Living Space
3,800 Sq.Ft.
Lot Area
1 Acres


In-law suite
Hardwood floors
Double height living room
Custom chef's kitchen
Ground floor master


Pool house w kitchenette
Cedar exterior
Metal standing-seam roof
Bluestone patio
Spa pool

Property Images

"Fabulous new construction home just a block and a half from Sag Harbor Village."
Alyra Hoffman

Want to tour this property?

Follow Us