34 Jermain Avenue, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963
34 Jermain Ave
6 beds
4,515 Sq.Ft.
1860 BUILT
0.45 Sq.Ft. LOT

Own a piece of history. This renovated circa 1860's Sag Harbor Village residence has it all. Sited on a small rise with idyllic views over Otter Pond, the fully cleared and manicured south-facing .46 acre property offers the rare Village trifecta: a 20 x 46 ft. heated salt-water pool and spa with marble patio, a pool house and substantial lawn for grand entertaining at home. 

The original classic Georgian style home has undergone a total ground up reconfiguration and addition totaling 4,700 sq. ft. in the main residence with a 487 sq. ft. 4-season pool house. In the main residence are 6 en-suite bedrooms and 6.5 baths with 3 wood-burning fireplaces. A double-height entry foyer leads to a parlor living room with a fireplace. A large eat-in kitchen is adjacent another living or dining room with fireplace and French doors onto a covered stone patio. Two private guest suites on the ground floor and 4 suites upstairs are flooded with natural light and generous walk-in closets. 

Master bedroom is upstairs with 2 large closets, a wood-burning fireplace and a private deck overlooking the grounds. There are two laundry rooms a mudroom, an enormous pantry and a finish-able partial basement. 

Pool house is complete with a lounge, a stunning full bath, marble kitchenette with dishwasher, and indoor-outdoor fireplace an attached garage, plenty of storage and dedicated furnace heat and air-conditiong mechanicals.

Sunsets over the pond, near the Mashashimuet Park with tennis courts, playing fields and trails, minutes down Captain's Row to the heart of what will always be an exciting cultural hub and picturesque fishing village surrounded by water.

Key Details

Total Bathrooms
Year Built
Living Space
4,515 Sq.Ft.
Lot Area
0.45 Sq.Ft.


Hardwood floors
5 fireplaces
Central air/ ohw
Partial basement


Unique pond views
1 car garage
26 x 46' heated salt water pool
Communal tennis court

Property Images

"This renovated circa 1860's Sag Harbor Village residence has it all."
Caroline Sarraf

Want to tour this property?

Follow Us