40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
SEE ALL PHOTOS
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd
Sold

40 Dinah Rock Rd

40 Dinah Rock Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$2,145,000

Picture a rural drive through farm fields and vineyards to a short ferry boat ride from Greenport’s harbor, then a scenic meander along Shelter Island’s picturesque coves. Continue passing through a golf course and arrive at your home in Hay Beach, across the street from a sandy shoreline with a magnificent sunset and bay views directly in front of your home.

This could be you this year.

The 1900 sq ft 3+ bedroom 3 bath shingled home is 100% turn-key renovated on a shy acre with a recently built 16 x 40’ heated salt-water Gunite pool in a sprawling sundrenched yard. Once inside, soaring double-height 20 ft ceilings meet you at the front door in a welcoming foyer. 

A recent thorough transformation included new oak floors, new stair balustrade, newel posts and handrails, and three stunning new baths, and a fully reimagined modern kitchen. The luminous loft-like open plan great room features a wall of glass with French doors to the backyard deck and a hearth-sized wood-burning fireplace anchoring a spacious (yet cozy) living room and dining area. The recently completed kitchen boasts premium Bertazzoni appliances and a generous 10.5-foot prep island with seating, ideal for both casual meals and mingling with guests.

On the ground floor, a large bonus room with an adjacent full bath functions as an extra 4th bedroom with a walk-in closet and ample room for a home office.

Upstairs are 2 well-sized guest bedrooms, one with water views, which share a hall bathroom. Connected by a bridge overlooking the living room and foyer is the sexy primary suite, which has water views and a superb spa bath with a rain showerhead and body sprays.

The unfinished lower level is partially above grade and presents as an easy future conversion to additional living space with a fireplace and plenty of natural light via windows and glass sliders offering access to the grassy backyard. 

This exceptional home combines tranquil living with proximity to many sandy beaches, Dering Harbor Village, and Gardiners Bay Country Club, providing an ideal setting to enjoy all the unique attractions Shelter Island offers.

3
beds

3
baths

0.92 Acres lot

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • total bedrooms3
  • Total bathrooms3
  • full bathrooms3
  • Flooring White Oak Hardwood Floors
  • Fireplace Wood Burning Fireplace
  • other interior Features Double-Height Cathedral Ceilings, First Floor Flex- Bedroom/ Den, Fully Renovated Turn-Key, Finishable Lower Level with fireplace and Walk- Out slider door to backyard

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Total Area1,897 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area0.92 Acres
  • YEAR BUILT2000
  • LifestylesBeach, Country Club, Country Living, Golf
  • Water FrontageWATER VIEWS

Exterior

  • STORIES2
  • PoolNew Salt water heated gunite pool
  • AIR CONDITIONINGCAC

Financial

  • Sales Price$2,145,000
40 Dinah Rock Rd
40 Dinah Rock Rd

What I truly love the most is that you can step actross the street and swim in a pristine beautiful bay beach.

– Caroline
40 Dinah Rock Rd

Picture a rural drive through farm fields and vineyards to a short ferry boat ride from Greenport’s harbor, then a scenic meander along Shelter Island’s picturesque coves. Continue passing through a golf course and arrive at your home in Hay Beach, across the street from a sandy shoreline with a magnificent sunset and bay views directly in front of your home.

This could be you this year.

The 1900 sq ft 3+ bedroom 3 bath shingled home is 100% turn-key renovated on a shy acre with a recently built 16 x 40’ heated salt-water Gunite pool in a sprawling sundrenched yard. Once inside, soaring double-height 20 ft ceilings meet you at the front door in a welcoming foyer. 

A recent thorough transformation included new oak floors, new stair balustrade, newel posts and handrails, and three stunning new baths, and a fully reimagined modern kitchen. The luminous loft-like open plan great room features a wall of glass with French doors to the backyard deck and a hearth-sized wood-burning fireplace anchoring a spacious (yet cozy) living room and dining area. The recently completed kitchen boasts premium Bertazzoni appliances and a generous 10.5-foot prep island with seating, ideal for both casual meals and mingling with guests.

On the ground floor, a large bonus room with an adjacent full bath functions as an extra 4th bedroom with a walk-in closet and ample room for a home office.

Upstairs are 2 well-sized guest bedrooms, one with water views, which share a hall bathroom. Connected by a bridge overlooking the living room and foyer is the sexy primary suite, which has water views and a superb spa bath with a rain showerhead and body sprays.

The unfinished lower level is partially above grade and presents as an easy future conversion to additional living space with a fireplace and plenty of natural light via windows and glass sliders offering access to the grassy backyard. 

This exceptional home combines tranquil living with proximity to many sandy beaches, Dering Harbor Village, and Gardiners Bay Country Club, providing an ideal setting to enjoy all the unique attractions Shelter Island offers.

Download Property Information

Our dynamic drive comes through in every transaction leaving no stone unturned and working tirelessly to negotiate the best possible deal for our clients.

Follow Me on Instagram