4594 Noyac Rd, Sag Harbor, NY
4594 Noyac Rd
4 beds
2 full baths
0.53 Acres LOT

Everyone loves Sag Harbor for the sunsets, the restaurants, design shops, the galleries, gourmet food shops, numerous coffee shops, the iconic movie and Bay Street theaters, the pier, marinas, and the enchanting small-town feel of the historic Village. Sag Harbor is best known for the community of wonderful, creative people that visit and reside here for the vibrant healthy lifestyle.


Our latest listing is in the heart of it all - an airy, bright, and immaculately maintained, fully renovated 4 bedroom home situated only 1 mile to the Village center. It's a fantastic house for entertaining family and friends with all the features you want in a summer or weekend house- private front and back yards, a heated pool, outdoor shower, jacuzzi hot tub, coupled with the intimate coziness of a year-round residence with a wood burning fireplace in the vaulted living room, and an open plan layout basking in natural daylight.

The cheerful kitchen has a center island and wine fridge. A glass side door takes you to the driveway to easily unload groceries. The dining area has sliders to the deck. The ground floor has a guest bedroom with an adjacent full bath with a tub. Upstairs are 3 bedrooms, a full bath with skylights, a double sink vanity, and a walk-in shower. The primary bedroom has convenient direct access to this bath; the other two guest bedrooms also share it.

The fully finished lower level is a huge bonus for last-minute overnight guests, game and movie nights, or just letting the kids run around on rainy days. There is also plenty of storage here and the laundry room.

The real fun is in the outdoors. There are multiple seating, lounging, and dining areas, a 16 x 32’ heated pool, plenty of lawn, and a remote-controlled retractable awning to mitigate the midday sun.

The detached one-car garage could be converted into a fabulous pool house or remain as excellent storage, and a garden shed adds to this compelling opportunity.

If you want a great investment, the property has had a very successful rental income over the past few years.

Set back from the road, this super-private and immediately loveable house is found between the Serene Green farm stand and the heart of the Village. Foster Memorial Long Beach and public tennis courts at Masashimuet Park are seconds away. You simply can't ask for more.

Area & Lot

For Sale
Total Area
2,400 Sq.Ft.
Lot Size
0.53 Acres
Sag Harbor


Total Bathrooms
Full Bathrooms
open kitchen
wood burning




Sales Price

Property Images


Sag Harbor

A port town with classic seaside charm.


Want to tour this property?

Follow Us