5 Carver Street, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963
5 Carver Street
4 beds
4 full baths
1 half bath
4,700 Sq.Ft.
2020 BUILT
0.37 Acres LOT

Sag Harbor Village has never been a more enticing place to call home. This highly anticipated 4,700 sq ft New Modern Farmhouse is the latest project by internationally published designers to come to an invigorating market where homes of this caliber are in strong demand.

We’ve aptly named it Carver House, with a nod to the classic rural themes which inspire the design - from the standing seam metal rooflines and an industrial grey tone-on-tone board and baton siding punctuated by six over six windows, to the entertainer’s dream kitchen fit for a boutique hotel. 

The generous .37acre property is tucked on a quiet residential street at the highest point in the Village offering peace and tranquility and magnificent sunset views over the town.  The house was designed to take advantage of these remarkable views with an intimate upstairs sitting room on the landing which opens to a large second story “courtyard” deck for private sun lounging and enjoying the magic hour at the end of every day.

On the ground floor, lofty 12 ft ceilings allow for a very bright open plan with seamless living and dining.  The heart of the house is the chef’s kitchen fitted with custom cabinetry with under counter lighting and wraparound Silestone counters and ample pantry storage.  A Bertazzoni appliance package includes 2 dishwashers, 2 sinks, a gas range in the center island, wine fridge, ice maker, and built-in microwave. The adjacent dining space will hold a great sized crowd when life allows it again!

Upstairs the master suite has superb views in every direction with an enormous spa bath with Carrera mosaic tile, an enviable “closet room” and direct access to the deck. Each of the 4 bedrooms has a thoughtfully designed bath. Fully finished on 3 levels there is plenty of room to spread everyone out with a flexible layout that could accommodate 2 private home offices and a Tv den which could serve as a 5th bedroom for overflow guests. The finished walk-out lower level is at grade elevation in the rear of the house and is configured as recreational space for media room/gym/studio all just steps from the pool with an oversized laundry room, home office, and access to the garage.

The garden is completely fenced, planted with evergreens, shrubs, and grasses all highlighted by an outdoor lighting package. A 16 x 36 ft heated Gunite pool is framed by a 200 sq ft pool house complete with built-in cabinetry holding a sink, wine fridge, and ice machine. There’s an outdoor shower and matching patios for lounging and outdoor dining.

Whether as a weekend retreat, second home or full-time residence, this property has it all and more with its unique sunset views, a stone’s throw from Haven’s Bay Beach and or Main Street where a year-round community has been busy setting their roots to create an active culturally stimulating town. What truly keeps Sag Harbor thriving is a backdrop of a friendly historic village surrounded by harbor and marinas where let’s face it… everyone wants to be at the end of the day.


Key Details

Full Bathrooms
Half Bathroom
Year Built
Living Space
4,700 Sq.Ft.
Lot Area
0.37 Acres


Lofty open plan
Enormous chef's kitchen
Ground floor junior master suite
Separate tv den
Powder room
Gas fireplace
Striking open tread stairwell
Dining space for 14
12'ceilings on ground floor
10'cielings on 2nd floor
Finshed lower level fully walk-out
2 home offices
1 car garage
Spacious laundry room
Upstairs master suite
Luxurious spa master bath
4 zone hvac
7" oak floors


Industrial chic modern farmhouse
Standing seam roof
Board and baton siding
Manicured grounds
Evergreen, birch , boxwood and native grass plantings
16 x 36 heated gunite pool
200sq ft pool house
Fully fenced yard
Outdoor lighting package
Wired for outdoor speakers

Property Images

"This truly is a home that has to be enjoyed all throughout the day... The Magical quality of light is heavenly!"

Sag Harbor

A port town with classic seaside charm.


Want to tour this property?